Skip to main content

packerboi posted:

Joe Whitt Jr. would make for a nice promotion to DC one day...

I agree. I just wonder why he has not been promoted before...perhaps another "assistant head coach in charge of something"

MM likes that title

Or maybe Whitt isn't DC material. Some guys are outstanding position coaches but don't cut it as coord's, some guys are outstanding as coord's but can't cut it as a HC, some guys are outstanding as HC, but can't cut it as the GM.

I think we all could list more than a few names, just from the Packers history, that fit the above.

I can't imagine how any team could know Whitt isn't DC material. He has a good rapport with his players and he's obviously a great teacher. That's almost always enough to get a position coach the chance to be a coordinator.

Whitt hasn't been around the league that much and more often than not I think coaches tend to hire people they know. Most teams only give a coach 3 or 4 years and I don't think many coaches are willing to roll the dice on a rookie coordinator they haven't worked with. They either want people they've worked with (people they know will ) or with people who are well known around the league. Whitt spent 7 years coaching in college, 1 season in Atlanta during Bobby Petrino's disastrous 2/3 of a season (as Asst. DB's coach) and the rest of the time he's been in GB. I'm not saying that's the only qualifier for becoming a DC, but I think it's probably the biggest thing holding him back because yeah his resume in GB is great. 

Last edited by Grave Digger

Whitt (or any Packers defensive coaches) isn't a hot commodity because Dom's defense isn't elite.  The reason the Seahawk's staff was raided was because their defense was top tier.  Similar to the Ravens defense when Billick was HC.  If the Packers D is top 5 for a couple of years, teams around the league will take notice of the coaching staff.

antooo posted:

Yet TT took notice of Mike McCarthy after a less than stellar debut as the OC of the 49'ers.  Basically an OC UDFA.

Lucky lapfaller.

More like McCarthy's resume as OC for the Saints had more to do with it.

I think McCarthy's personality and philosophy had more to do with it. Thompson spoke early on and has said many time since that he wanted someone he could work with who shared his philosophy for running a team. McCarthy was a gamble for TT, just liked Rodgers was. The '05 offseason and the '06 offseason TT showed balls of iron...lets two popular OL walk, drafts a QB with a beloved franchise QB on the roster, fires the HC, hires the OC from a crappy 49ers offense, and the rest is history. 

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×