Skip to main content

 

At the official end of the free-agency period on Wednesday, the Packers still had seven free agents unsigned: LS Brett Goode WR James James FB John Kuhn OLB Mike Neal TE Andrew Quarless S Sean Richardson NT B.J. Raji (who is taking the year off) It doesn't mean players can't still be signed, but now they don't count in the compensatory draft pick formula for next year.

Yes, I'm certain every GM in the NFL would pass on Rodgers with at least 101 other players first.

In PFF's defense they were talking about the 2015 season performance ONLY. With that criteria, perhaps, Rodgers wasn't in the top 101.

However, There's no way I'd choose any other QB in the league over Rodgers.

I gotta be honest, I thought A. Rodgers was frightfully mediocre for about 1/2 the season.  Going into last year, most thought you could put a bunch of bums around Rodgers and he'd elevate their level of play.  Last year was the first time I've seen Rodgers not elevate others around him, and I thought he let the ineptitude around him affect his own level of play.  

Do I think it was a fluke?  Yes, and I think having a little bit more of a supporting cast will help him return to his past greatness.  That said, Rodgers played at a shaky level of play I never thought I'd see from him and that was an eye opener.

PFF is great at charting individual players' game stats and team stats as well. That has value.

Where PFF falls down is then subjectively trying to rate or rank player performances by game and by season. They're no better than any other swinging d***s out there at that, but are so sanctimonious about how good their ratings are and how they just can't be wrong that they lose credibility. Caveat emptor.

Last edited by ilcuqui
fightphoe93 posted:

I gotta be honest, I thought A. Rodgers was frightfully mediocre for about 1/2 the season.  Going into last year, most thought you could put a bunch of bums around Rodgers and he'd elevate their level of play.  Last year was the first time I've seen Rodgers not elevate others around him, and I thought he let the ineptitude around him affect his own level of play.  

Do I think it was a fluke?  Yes, and I think having a little bit more of a supporting cast will help him return to his past greatness.  That said, Rodgers played at a shaky level of play I never thought I'd see from him and that was an eye opener.

There were times I swear I saw an unusual hitch in his throwing motion.  I'm fairly certain something was hurting him, but of course, they never talked about it.  

I respect that PFF takes the time to assign a score to each player based on specific plays, but in the end each grade is their opinion. PFF can only grade what they see unlike the coaches who know the specific play and assignment. What they may call a bad throw may be a blown assignment by the WR...what PFF calls a missed block by the LG may actually be a blown call by the C or QB. They're not looking at the league and picking their favorite 100 players, they're picking the 100 highest scores from the season based on their opinion. That has merit, but at its core it's no different than a useless draft site...they know what they're seeing, but they're passing judgement with half or less of the overall picture. TFWIW.

From packers.com:

Packers sign S Jermaine Whitehead
Auburn alum spent rookie season in '15 with 49ers, Ravens


The Green Bay Packers have signed S Jermaine Whitehead. Ted Thompson, Executive Vice President, General Manager and Director of Football Operations, announced the signing Wednesday.

Whitehead, a 5-foot-11, 195-pound first-year player out of Auburn, entered the NFL as an undrafted free agent with the San Francisco 49ers on May 5, 2015. He spent most of his rookie season on the 49ers’ practice squad before being signed to the Baltimore Ravens’ active roster on Dec. 23, 2015. Whitehead was inactive for the final two games of the season and re-signed with the Ravens on April 19, 2016, before being waived on May 13. He will wear No. 35 for the Packers.

Last edited by ilcuqui

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×