Not enough guys from the 1977-1983 era. Team was absolutely loaded.
4 Future HOFers: Yount, Molitor, Sutton, Fingers,
Guys with multiple all-star games (and not the token guy in years where they sucked) that aren't HOFers: Simmons, Cooper, Oglivie, Don Money. Vuckovich won a Cy Young, Gorman Thomas made an all-star team and lead the league in HRs twice. Caldwell went 79-48 over a 5 year period and was runner up for a Cy Young in 1978 (to Guidry's 25-3 year).
SP. Sheets, Greinke, Mike Caldwell, Higuera, Bosio, Vuckovich, Sabathia, Eldred
RP. Fingers, Plesac, Ladd, Hader
C. Ted Simmons, Lucroy, Surhoff
1B. Cecil Cooper, George Scott, Fielder
2B. Gantner, Weeks,
3B. Molitor, Don Money
SS. Robin Yount, Hardy, Sheffield, Sveum
OF. Braun, Yelich, Oglivie, Cain, G. Thomas, Greg Vaughn, Hisle, Yount
DH. Parker, Molitor