The Packers in my lifetime have always been #1 to me and were like that even in the dark years.
Growing up near GB as a kid I would say the Brewers were always my second choice and the Bucks who I liked a lot and I followed but they were still third to me. Growing up the Badgers were so terrible but I rooted for them but usually saying to myself "damn they are bad"
Now? its still the Packers by far and away number 1 and the Badgers are easily second. I hate to say it but I have been gone from home for so long I barely watch the Bucks and only pay much attention to the Brewers if they are in the playoffs.