You presented 2 different choices, which one would you choose
1. TT "goes for it", the defense gets better, and the offense keep humming along. You see that in the next 5 years. the Packers win a Super Bowl, and make the playoffs 2 other years ( No Super Bowl win ), miss playoffs 2 other years.
2. Ted sits on his hands, and keeps doing what he does. The Packers make the playoffs all 5 years. 2 of those years they make it to the NFC Championship ( 1 in Green Bay, and 1 on the road ), but you do not know the outcome of either NFC title game.
Which one would you choose?