Tramon Williams Vs Davon House

Gotta be House. He's an ascending player and he's 6 years younger.

House and save millions off the bat with similar production.

Now, I do like Tramon and believe him to be the better CB at this time, but House is younger and is becoming one heck of a CB and I love his size and speed.  I'd go with House!

Heck, I was high on House prior to this season and even before the Boss jumped on his band wagon.   I told yah!

Williams can play another 4 years.

Sign both for reasonable deals

I was down on Tramon for a while but i'm starting to think that shoulder injury lingered for a long long time.  He is playing great this year, hard to let a guy like that walk.  

It all depends on what each guys market value is and if either is willing to take the home town discount.   Reading the articles on JSonline, I think House is just going to go to the highest bidder.  

Will see if Tramon wants the coin or wants more rings. 

It's pretty hard to trump experience and Williams has plenty of it. Which is what Capers and Dick at Pittsburgh claims they'll take over youth.

I don't know if Boris' prediction would be true that Williams has another 4 years in him but I would buy he at least has another 2, maybe 3. I look back to Woodson. In 2009, he was the best DB in the NFL. In 2010, still fairly dominant. But in '11, a noticeable drop off very quickly.

That'd be my concern with re-signing him at a big contract. My guess is Ted would offer a 3 year deal, heavily loaded in year 1, in the neighborhood of 6-7 mil a year.

And thanks to clown organizations like the Vikings, Redskins, or Raiders Williams will have little desire to sign that. Because we all know they'll grossly overpay.

If you can only sign one, House is the guy.  I think they'll try to keep both unless Williams prices himself out of GB's market. 

That makes a lot sense on the experience and the $$ side pboi -

http://overthecap.com/salary-cap-space/

GB still has $7.7 M in cap space for 2014 and both players want to be in GB

House didn't enjoy all the losing at New Mexico State

If only one, you go with House. I too think they'll figure out a way to keep both. squawk

Yvonne, Renée and Loretta in What the Parrot Saw.

There's not much of a sample size with House to simply assume he's the next best thing at the CB position.  Up until this season he's been hurt and wildly inconsistent. 

Tramon has had a very good career with the exception of about 20 games which I think was related to his injury.   His performance (now) is much more what we've come to expect out of him going back to 2010.

If the dollars were equal and I could only choose one guy I'd pick Tramon.   However, if House can prove the rest of this season is not a fluke perhaps I'd change my mind. 

The other factor is Casey Hayward.  Personally, I'd take him over the other two guys in a heartbeat.   It just seems like it's a different defense when he's in there.

He has a knack for getting the ball when he's the 4th CB on the field. I don't know if his coverage skills are up to snuff to be a full time starting CB at this point, yet.

House lost a lot of money tonight and Tramon gained some leverage.

Except for the two touchdowns Tramon gave up tonight.

Tramon has shown he can play at a high level against good QB's, House hasn't.

I will never forget the 2010 playoff game against Atlanta. Matt Ryan must have nightmares about the guy. He knocked down at least 4 passes, and took one 70 yards to the house for a TD. 

I need to see that kind of ability from House.

Hayward is a star in the making, imo. The guy is a ball hawk. He had the best corner back rating in the NFL as a rookie. That's mighty impressive if you ask me. 

According to @PFF, Drew Brees completed 6 of 6 passes in the direction of #Packers CB Tramon Williams for 102 yards and 2 TDs, 158.3 rating.
— Brian Carriveau (@BrianCarriveau) October 27, 2014

 He ain't got it, man.  Too stiff in the hips and hands of stone.  He can show up from time to time where he doesn't need those traits but he will never be a Tramon.

The speed of Shields and Burnett (gasp) were sorely missed last night on the carpet.  I hope we can finally stop heaping expectations on Hyde.  He's "a football player" but works best in the dime, not as a starting S.  

I agree with that on Hyde.

Hayward's a prototypical zone slot corner where his lack of pure speed is covered.

Agree with Herschel on this one.   Heyward is perfect for the role he has.  If you put him outside he will probably struggle with his speed in man to man.