AR Best in 22 Years

That's my #1 boyfriend.   He's just the best.....        

Impressive for Rodgers. 

Not so impressive for Favre. 

quote:

That's my #1 boyfriend.   He's just the best.....

But when the game was on the line he never choked.

And the TD bomb to Javon Walker against the Giants proved he was just as good unconscious as he was conscious.

Apparently somebody didn't watch the Cardinals game where he couldn't even lead the offense to a touchdown.

Even Vince Young is 33rd

ROTTTT

I've always thought Favre was at his best when he was unconcious.

Starks poked that ball over the GL on 4th down. But whatever. It's preseason for the stripes too.

Obviously, this author of this article doesn't realize that AR has never had many 4th Q comebacks, and it's my understanding that in order to be considered a good QB, you have to lead your team to a comeback in the 4th Q.  

Holds onto the ball too long. Hard to consider him elite until he learns to throw it away and not take the sack.

it's all about rings and team.  what's with all this ego-driven play for personal QBR ratings?!?!?!  

You can't name me 5 3 QB's in the game today better than Rodgers

Just because he takes a sack & sometimes holds the ball too long doesn't mean he's NOT elite

Did someone say "Elite"?

He's no Kevin Kolb

I can't name one that I think is better than AR. That said, he was (unofficially) given responsibility for ten sacks last year and that's one aspect of his game that does need some work.

While there's no doubt the first 4 guys belong in that top 4, the rest of that list pretty much looks like a joke.

Am I missing something? I looked through the list twice and didn't see Ponder.