Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Iowa has as good of a defense as any team in college football.  Special teams are also really good.  

But Deacon Hill has to be literally the worst QB of any major conference team in the country.  He makes Mike Samuel look like Drake Maye.

As for the playoff, well someone will get screwed.  I donโ€™t see a scenario where Alabama and Georgia both make it and itโ€™s possible Ohio State gets left out as well.  Thatโ€™s a bunch of crap.  Florida State has no business being considered but if they make it in itโ€™s likely two of those three teams mentioned wonโ€™t because of Texas.  Then thereโ€™s Washington that had a ton of close victories but I question just how good the PAC 2 really is.

To me, the 4 best teams at Michigan, Ohio State, Georgia and Bama.

Last edited by Tschmack

FSU has a legitimate right to be pissed.  Results on the field are what should matter.  We can look at the SEC and say that it's a better conference, but is it?  What evidence this year supports that?  Alabama played one out of conference game against a power 5 opponent and lost.  Georgia's best OOC win came against mighty Georgia Tech.  Who from the SEC won a big OOC game?  We can look at Bama and Georgia and say that they are better, but why aren't they penalized for not scheduling tougher opponents?  FSU beat two SEC teams out of conference and should be in based on on-field performance over perception.

@Goalline posted:

Iโ€™m not quite sure why you all insist on arguing about this. First of all, designating 4 teams means someone is going to get screwed. That gets rectified next year. Secondly, this shit needs to be put in writing. This process is so not transparent.

Does it really matter if you go with 4, 8 or 12 teams.   If you go with 8 the #( team will be pissed.  If you go with 12 the #13 team will be pissed.   If you went with 124 teams the #125 will be pissed.   

@ammo posted:

Does it really matter if you go with 4, 8 or 12 teams.   If you go with 8 the #( team will be pissed.  If you go with 12 the #13 team will be pissed.   If you went with 124 teams the #125 will be pissed.   

Yes, but the #9 team is highly unlikely to win the big one. IMO, playoffs work best when you allow 1 or 2 teams in who donโ€™t really have a chance. That way, everyone who deserves to get in actually gets the chance.

Last edited by Goalline

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×