Skip to main content

So this is another twist in the NFL's everlasting questionable handling of concussions. In this case, the league has put the onus on the player.

According to the Associated Press, Packers left tackle David Bakhtiari re-entered Sunday's loss to the San Francisco 49ers with a concussion. Two players violated league concussion protocol last weekend, according to a letter sent by the NFL's head, neck and spine committee to all NFL team doctors and trainers, the AP reports.

The other player is New Orleans Saints cornerback Keenan Lewis.

 

Bakhtiari went into the game for an extra point attempt despite being diagnosed with a concussion and not being cleared. In the letter, the NFL's committee essentially blames the tackle himself, saying it finds "no fault" in the medical staffs.

 

"On two occasions last weekend, and contrary to the advice of the team medical staffs, players who had been diagnosed with a concussion and therefore declared ineligible for play nonetheless refused to leave the sidelines as required by league concussion protocols," the letter said in the report. "In one case, the player went back onto the field for one play before being removed from the game.

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Bakhtiari nearly sprinted to the locker room to get tested. The fact that he was able to get back on the field should put the protocol in question, not the inability of the team to keep him off the field. 

 

If he didn't know whether he was foot or horseback he shouldn't have been of the mind to know to go in for an XP. (IIRC, on XPs he is on the right end, not his normal LT spot.)

 

 

Originally Posted by Hungry5:

Bakhtiari nearly sprinted to the locker room to get tested. The fact that he was able to get back on the field should put the protocol in question, not the inability of the team to keep him off the field. 

 

If he didn't know whether he was foot or horseback he shouldn't have been of the mind to know to go in for an XP. (IIRC, on XPs he is on the right end, not his normal LT spot.)

 

 

I saw him sprinting to the LR and thought that was odd. I took it to mean he was pissed off about being held out and he wanted to go into the LR and hopefully get cleared to return to the game ASAP.

 

I think the protocol is so sensitive now that many players who are held out are not mentally disoriented after resting for 15 minutes after a mild concussion. And they feel well enough to return.

Last edited by FreeSafety

@Free, that was my intent if not my point on the protocol. I think Bakhtiari's failed test during the game, and what about Franklin (I don't have a neck injury) going to IR from a concussion, puts in question the sensitivity of the protocol/tests. The League has gone as far as they probably can get away with versus what the NFLPA might like with regards to the sensitivity / protocol actions. Eleventy-billion $$ settlements against your organization probably does that.

 

 

Exactly.  That's a freaking FANTASTIC point!  Fad diets starting because some people lost weight after discovering an allergy is EXACTLY the same as a skyrocketing number of people involved in regular collisions dying early for reasons including Lou Gherig's disease and CTE.

 

VERY astute analogy!

 

Not to downplay stupidity... but that whole post is worse than the 'Colin Cowherd teaches me things about life' opinion.

Last edited by JJSD
Originally Posted by JJSD:

Exactly.  That's a freaking FANTASTIC point!  Fad diets starting because some people lost weight after discovering an allergy is EXACTLY the same as a skyrocketing number of people involved in regular collisions dying early for reasons including Lou Gherig's disease and CTE.

 

VERY astute analogy!

 

Not to downplay stupidity... but that whole post is worse than the 'Colin Cowherd teaches me things about life' opinion.

I will withhold my opinion on this until chimes in

If you have Celiac disease, which my daughter has, the new awareness of gluten in food is very important.  Just a little gluten in her diet makes her very sick.  It's great that some restaurants now are aware of what gluten is and know how to make gluten-free dishes and some even have a separate gluten-free menu.  And, many more supermarkets now have a separate isle with gluten-free foods.  For my daughter, being gluten-free is not a trend or a fad diet.  It's a necessity of life.

I wonder what people did before we had all the diagnosis? But, back to Bak, the guy is a keeper. It's the attitude we want. Okay, so he might not be that smart to want to go back if he truly had a serious enough concussion but his attitude has helped make him a starter as a rookie. I look for him to be a stud somewhere on the line next year.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×