When NY scored and made it 20-12 with 4 minutes left you HAVE to go for 2. You instantly improve odds. Make it 20-14 and get a stop a TD and XP wins it. Don’t make it and get a stop a TD and 2pt ties it. 2 tries at 2 points is better than 1. Unless you think OT are better odds. They’re not
NY just didn’t get the stop.