Skip to main content

As it relates to the centralization of replay review, a topic that has been a sore point for multiple coaches and team executives who worry that this will allow the league office to make decisions aimed at reaching outcomes desired by 345 Park Avenue, Goodell outlined the new procedure that would be adopted: “Instead of a fixed sideline monitor, we will bring a tablet to the Referee who can review the play in consultation with our officiating headquarters in New York, which has the final decision. This should improve consistency and accuracy of decisions and help speed up the process.”

It also should allow Microsoft to get even more bang for its product-placement buck, with the peep-show approach replaced by an official using the official tablet of the National Football League, complete with that distinctive electric blue case.

Apart from the obvious change to the appearance of the replay review process, the new approach would result in the referee losing final say over the outcome, with the league office having the power to overrule the ruling on the field.

So why involve the referee at all? Doing so eliminates the sense that the decision is being made remotely (and possibly arbitrarily). In fairness to the league, it also allows for an extra set of eyes, which is never a bad thing. And, as mentioned above, it provides for greater integration of the Microsoft tablet into the presentation of the game. Which makes that partnership even more valuable to the league.

Especially when the time comes to put the official tablet sponsorship out for bidding.

So Microsoft gets exposure leading to more corporate money. And Ref's are allowed to be overruled.

http://profootballtalk.nbcspor...ay-system-will-work/

Vikings fans should love this when they play GB. I'm sure they won't have any issue when the Ref rules in favor of the Packers. Then again, anytime the Patriots get a ruling, the rest of the league....

Last edited by packerboi
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Every day, it seems I care less about the NFL.

Why even have refs on the field? It's the most ridiculous thing I've ever seen when a 60 something ref is trying to keep up with a world class athlete. 

might be more excited about this possibility if it were used to correct bad calls, especially those involving "targeting", blows to the head, and/or unnecessary roughness. I'm all for the league making a correct ruling, but can't trust 'em any further than I could throw 'em.
Speaking of, I also read where there may be a proposal to eject players from games with these kind of hits. I'm much more worried about how the refs would interpret such, and there being no recourse for a team to challenge these for replay.

Speaking of, I also read where there may be a proposal to eject players from games with these kind of hits. I'm much more worried about how the refs would interpret such, and there being no recourse for a team to challenge these for replay.

Doesn't the college game already do this?

And it's not just the NFL.  Earlier this season Montreal Canadiens' goalie Carey Price violated a rule which is supposed to mean automatic ejection, but because he plays for an Original Six team the league did nothing.  Kind of like the way the NFL tried to sweep Warren Sapp's dirty hit on Chad Clifton under the rug. 

Fedya posted:

Speaking of, I also read where there may be a proposal to eject players from games with these kind of hits. I'm much more worried about how the refs would interpret such, and there being no recourse for a team to challenge these for replay.

Doesn't the college game already do this?

What, rely on the NFL front office to make their replay calls?

Don't see the downside. Those of us at home know the call before the ref is even under the hood. Speed it up, get it right and move on. (And yes, that's the date night mantra around the ILPF house.)

NHL refs are handed a tablet and in conjunction with league office, do replay. It does take less time. They can also review coaches' challenges. The NFL is just copying what the NHL already does.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×