Lets talk about a few guys of interest...
Brett Lawrie- OPS is .647. OBP is horrible, but he has crushed a few home runs, which helps the slugging (which is still a mediocre .388). He's started to warm up, then sat out a game with back trouble.
Corey Hart- OPS is .743, meh OBP and SLG (Reynolds has a higher OPS, granted in a platoon, but also in the same number of AB's). Primarily a DH, but he has taking the field in right for 3 games (I'm shocked).
Juan Francisco- Here is the guy I preferred over Overbay. Only 40 AB's as he started out in the minors, but he has raked since he got called up. OPS over 900 and SLG over 500. O played batter defense (Juan manned third when Lawrie was out, he's not good there), but I still hold Juan would have been a better choice in the platoon. We are talking about 40 AB's for both guys, but I think the upside is higher for Juan and we are getting what we are going to get from O.
Zack Greinke- well, he's pitching pretty damn well.
Manny Parra- it seems hitters can still hit Manny
Nyger Morgan- Tony Plush has really taken advantage of his 23 AB's in the Majors. Good for him.
John Axford- John has 8 saves and is keeping guys from scoring. Walk rate is still high, K rate is low, I'd be worried about Ax keeping guys from scoring all year long.
Jake Odorizzi- I wouldn't kick him out of my system, but he has not shown in his limited time. WHIP is 1.8, maybe if he settles down he can turn it around.
Alcides Escobar- He is really shining right now. Had a great April and still plays good defense.