Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

With Ty Summers finally gone and Dexter Williams about to get his walking papers for the second time, that leaves exactly ZERO (0) players left on the roster out of the 14 who were drafted outside of rounds 1 & 2 during the 2018 and 2019 drafts.

Moreover, only MVS among these 14 draftees ever contributed anything of note.

Considering that STs contributors are generally are found in the later rounds of the draft and that at least 2 of the picks below were specifically dedicated to STs (Scott & Bradley), the lack of production out of the 2018-2019 post 2nd round picks has undoubtedly contributed to the Pack's poor STs play.

2018 DRAFT

Round Three (#88 overall): Oren Burks, ILB, Vanderbilt

Round Four (#133 overall): J’Mon Moore, WR, Missouri

Round Five (#138 overall): Cole Madison, G, Washington State

Round Five (#172 overall) JK Scott, P, Alabama

Round Five (#174 overall): Marquez Valdes-Scantling, WR, South Florida

Round Six (#207 overall) Equanimeous St. Brown, WR, Notre Dame

Round Seven, (#232 overall): James Looney, DE, California

Round Seven (#239 overall): Hunter Bradley, Ls, Mississippi State

Round Seven (#248 overall): Kendall Donnerson, Edge, Southeast Missouri State

2019 DRAFT

Round Three (#75 overall): Jace Sternberger, TE, Texas A&M

Round Five (#150 overall): Kingsley Keke, DT, Texas A&M

Round Six (#185 overall): Ka’Dar Hollman, CB, Toledo
          (#194 overall): Dexter Williams, RB, Notre Dame

Round Seven (#226 overall) Ty Summers, LB, TCU

Gute hit home runs in round 1 of the 2018 and 2019 drafts in Alexander and Gary, respectively and in round 2 of the 2019 draft in Jenkins and Savage has proven to be a decent 2019 round 1 pick, but the post-round 2 picks during the 2018 and 2019 drafts (outside of MVS) did not, unfortunately, contribute much of anything.

@SteveLuke posted:


Gute hit home runs in round 1 of the 2018 and 2019 drafts in Alexander and Gary, respectively and in round 2 of the 2019 draft in Jenkins and Savage has proven to be a decent 2019 round 1 pick, but the post-round 2 picks during the 2018 and 2019 drafts (outside of MVS) did not, unfortunately, contribute much of anything.

And this really underlines the greatness of a Ron Wolf...dude hit gold all over the draft.

@Goalline posted:

You mean like TBuck, Dr. John Michels, Antuwan Edwards and Jamal Reynolds?



What about future Hall of Famers, Robert "Turd" Ferguson, Fred Vinson(thanks for Ahman Green)?

No, more like Edgar Bennett, Robert Brooks, Mark Chmura, Earl Dotson, Dorsey Levens, Bill Schroeder, Adam Timmerman, William Henderson, Antonio Freeman, Mike Flanagan, Tyrone Williams, Marco Rivera, Donald Driver, etc. All 3rd round or later guys.

Didn't say he was perfect, just said he was great at D&D before it was the in thing.

@vitaflo posted:

I agree with you but lets be fair, Lancaster and Yosh were UDFA in '18 and '19 respectively.  Both contributed.

Good points re UDFAs though I'd say Lancaster filled a roster spot rather than contributing that much to the team (he was also not good on STs FWIW).

And it is also fair to point out that, unlike Ted, Gute is much more willing to cast around for players on other teams to make up for any drafting misses.

Amos, Z. and P. Smith are obvious examples of this willingness, but getting Campbell and Douglas off the scrap heap to be big-time contributors were just awesome moves that need to be commended.

Still, by any measure, it was a disappointing return out the 14 players drafted after rounds 1-2 in 2018 and 2019.

@Chongo posted:

No, more like Edgar Bennett, Robert Brooks, Mark Chmura, Earl Dotson, Dorsey Levens, Bill Schroeder, Adam Timmerman, William Henderson, Antonio Freeman, Mike Flanagan, Tyrone Williams, Marco Rivera, Donald Driver, etc. All 3rd round or later guys.

Didn't say he was perfect, just said he was great at D&D before it was the in thing.

And I am just going to acknowledge that Gute has been our best high draft pick drafter. Since 1991. He doesn't get enough credit for that from the X4 knuckleheads.

@Chongo posted:

Only way they cut Mason is if he isn't going to physically be ready...salary cap savings wouldn't be that great...then you lose his leadership, one of 12's BFF...just don't think it's worth cutting him unless he physically can't go.

Who knows - It may just be a cap maneuver...release him now with a handshake agreement to bring him back next week. That cleanses his current deal and while the cap savings are minimal, they're not zero. And GB is pretty tight against it

If they were gonna actually move on from Mason, I don't think he'd be hanging around practice and in the facility like he has been.

I would have think Gute at least inquires, and no I do not expect him to be signed but this is a ST's unit with a lot of ? marks going into this season, not to mention they are thin at S:

    #Jaguars are releasing safety and special teams ace Rudy Ford, source said. Had a role last year on defense and the new coaching staff only viewed him in ST role. Multiple teams attempted a trade but his $2M salary was prohibitive and he’s now available on open market.

Its all fun and games for us, but for the players involved - its a real gut punch

Andrew Brandt from the wayback machine  (2013)

You think its easy to cut a guy ?

https://www.si.com/nfl/2013/08/08/nfl-preseason-cuts

If you think training camps are about having an open competition, guess again. Teams have proprietary depth charts going into camp, different from the ones shared with the media. There are usually between four and six spots that are open to competition, depending largely on numbers and personnel groupings rather than the performance of players on the bubble.

For instance, if we had a couple of young offensive linemen we wanted to keep on the roster for any number of reasonsβ€”it could even be the limited practice availability of older linemenβ€”we would β€œgo heavy” up front. This would mean the end of the road for a sixth linebacker, a fifth safety or a fourth running back. Every team makes these roster decisions that affect players at other positions regardless of their performance.

During my nine seasons as the Packers' vice president, coaches and personnel staff gathered to determine who stayed and who had to go, often with differing opinions about players. Doctors were consulted on injury-affected players, and I would present cash and salary cap implications of various roster scenarios. After deliberations and much lobbyingβ€”position coaches usually wanted more numbers for their unitβ€”we would finally settle on a list that no player ever wants to be on: The Cut List.

The Cut List was stark in its simplicity. It would not have names, just jersey numbers, perhaps to facilitate cleaning out the lockers. The list was held and managed by pro personnel director Reggie McKenzie, who is now general manager of the Raiders. I would listen to Reggie go down the list and check off the players as he uttered his trademark line to them, β€œSorry big fella, but we’re gonna have to let you go.”

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×