Skip to main content

That would actually be awesome.

Here’s a weird “what if” scenario: the draft is loaded at RB so teams may feel they can wait. What do you do if Ashton Jeanty is on the board at #23? He’d easily be the proverbial “Best Player Available”, so would you draft him regardless of need?

I doubt he’s there, of course, but the same could hold true for someone like Malachi Starks at Safety. If you truly want to compete for a championship now, how much need and “positional value” are you willing to overlook?

@Herschel posted:

That would actually be awesome.

Here’s a weird “what if” scenario: the draft is loaded at RB so teams may feel they can wait. What do you do if Ashton Jeanty is on the board at #23? He’d easily be the proverbial “Best Player Available”, so would you draft him regardless of need?

I doubt he’s there, of course, but the same could hold true for someone like Malachi Starks at Safety. If you truly want to compete for a championship now, how much need and “positional value” are you willing to overlook?

He would be very tempting to take him if he lasts that long.  But, I think they desperately need to upgrade pass rusher, CB, and WR way before they need a RB.  If they want RB depth they could always find one in a later round.   

Latest Daniel Jeremiah mock has us taking this guy...we could do worse than a versatile OT from tOSU...although "coming off a knee injury" concerns me more than "coming off a shoulder injury" did last year...and that concerned me a lot.

Pick
23
Josh Simmons
Ohio State · OT · Junior (RS)

Simmons is coming off a knee injury, but he’s as gifted as any offensive lineman in the class. He also has the tools to play multiple spots on the O-line, something Green Bay has always valued.

Patellar tendon tear...not awful but not great...from Googles about recovery:

For an athlete, returning to sports after a torn patellar tendon typically takes 6 to 12 months, with most needing surgery to repair a complete rupture, and a significant amount of physical therapy to regain full function and strength in the knee; the exact timeframe depends on the severity of the tear and individual healing factors.




Well, TBF, the only mocks that are remotely accurate with regard to the Packers come from Bob McGinn...so I don't think Jeremiah is going to be accurate here.

My guess is we either trade back, or take a player none of us have ever heard of/considered as of Feb 2025.

These NFL Draft Honks do not enjoy the deep tracks that Gutey has an ear for...he's scouring the Jethro Tull B-Sides right now....

@Herschel posted:

I'm curious to know the official weigh in of Charles Grant from William & Mary. He's similar to Z.Tom in that he appears pretty athletic and versatile but could use some bulk. Nfl.com lists him at 300# even at this point, which could be accurate since he supposedly played at 291# this season.

Big fan of Grey Zabel, OT from NDSU...probably will go higher than the Packers would be looking to take him, but I believe like Tom, he is athletic enough to play multiple spots on the OL.

Because the one thing we don’t know is if the best guys from college can do is play football.

Interviews and especially medical tests are huge for these guys. On field drills are good comparisons for similarly-ranked guys or a chance to see if back-end guys have something to set them apart enough.

Take someone like Kain Medrano from UCLA: good college linebacker but marginal pro prospect. He’s pretty small for the pros at 222#, but fast. GM-A thinks he might be fast enough to take a late-round shot or free agent offer for at least special teams even with his lack of size. Guy comes out and runs a sub-4.5 40. GM-A has some more confirmation the speed he saw on tape is legit when compared to the best prospects in the draft.

Last edited by Herschel
@Herschel posted:

That would actually be awesome.

Here’s a weird “what if” scenario: the draft is loaded at RB so teams may feel they can wait. What do you do if Ashton Jeanty is on the board at #23? He’d easily be the proverbial “Best Player Available”, so would you draft him regardless of need?

I doubt he’s there, of course, but the same could hold true for someone like Malachi Starks at Safety. If you truly want to compete for a championship now, how much need and “positional value” are you willing to overlook?

RB Bijan Robinson was the last "generational" RB available in the Draft. Gute passed on him, meaning,  he did not move up to get him. Robinson went pick #8, to Atlanta, in the 2023 NFL Draft. The Packers drafted Van Ness at the 13th spot, in that draft.

Remember the Aaron Rogers draft when the cameras kept watching him squirm as he was passed over time and time again?

I’ve decided I want that and MORE to happen to Shedeur Sanders this April. I’m just so sick of the Sanders hype machine. The kid hasn’t played a single snap in the NFL and he’s already demanding that teams listen to him. It’s just so annoying. I can just imagine what Vince Lombardi would have thought of him.

https://247sports.com/article/...t-combine-246296641/

@RoyalWulff posted:

Remember the Aaron Rogers draft when the cameras kept watching him squirm as he was passed over time and time again?

I’ve decided I want that and MORE to happen to Shedeur Sanders this April. I’m just so sick of the Sanders hype machine. The kid hasn’t played a single snap in the NFL and he’s already demanding that teams listen to him. It’s just so annoying. I can just imagine what Vince Lombardi would have thought of him.

https://247sports.com/article/...t-combine-246296641/

The media is complicit in this sham. Were he just another athlete, not from the loins of Deion, he wouldn't be getting near this amount of hype.

But someone is going to be dumb enough to take him in R1. Then we will hear for the next 5 years how nothing is his fault. It won't happen because they just got their next bust, but there was never anyone that was more destined to be a Bear than Shadeur.

@RoyalWulff posted:

Remember the Aaron Rogers draft when the cameras kept watching him squirm as he was passed over time and time again?

I’ve decided I want that and MORE to happen to Shedeur Sanders this April. I’m just so sick of the Sanders hype machine. The kid hasn’t played a single snap in the NFL and he’s already demanding that teams listen to him. It’s just so annoying. I can just imagine what Vince Lombardi would have thought of him.

https://247sports.com/article/...t-combine-246296641/

Oh I think Vincent  Lombardi would have had no reservations passing on him if he didn't  think  he wouldn't fit in the "team".

One tried  and  true thing about the draft is that one team will believe  the hype, is dumb historically, or the organization is desperate for a QB in order to save jobs will take him.   The first 3 teams in the draft TN, Cleveland, and NYG all need a qb and one of them I think just might pull the trigger.

Round 6-7, probably.  He's really raw and has short arms. Did have a good Senior Bowl, though, so someone will probably throw a pick at him.

Another guy they could be interested in on Day 3 as even a bit taller version of MVS is Dont'e Thornton from Tennessee. He ran faster than I thought he would with a 4.30 40. He gives effort as a blocker, though he wasn't really beefy enough to move non-DBs.

https://www.nfl.com/prospects/...99-da64-33f3c8b0bd34

Jayden Higgins probably made some money this weekend. The big question was sufficient speed and he ran a 4.47.

Antwan Wells probably lost money. He was a 'cock transfer to Ole Miss and didn't have a good year. He was maybe a "his best year wasn't his last" candidate but he measured in at 6'1" and ran a relatively poor 4.58.

Last edited by Herschel

Swinson seems awfully light for a Gutekunst edge. I'd love a bendy guy but Gutekunst seems more enamored with stout edges who are 270# early/with resources (Preston, Z'Darius, Gary, Van Ness, even James Looney late).

That kind of leaves Jared Ivey, Jordan Burch, Sai'vion Jones, Elijah Roberts and Tyler Batty with Burch and maybe Ivey the only early round guys.

Even Shemar Stewart was #267.

@Herschel posted:

Swinson seems awfully light for a Gutekunst edge. I'd love a bendy guy but Gutekunst seems more enamored with stout edges who are 270# early/with resources (Preston, Z'Darius, Gary, Van Ness, even James Looney late).

That kind of leaves Jared Ivey, Jordan Burch, Sai'vion Jones, Elijah Roberts and Tyler Batty with Burch and maybe Ivey the only early round guys.

Even Shemar Stewart was #267.

BPA at that slot...I wasn't just going to pick some shitty safety from Iowa there.

@Chongo posted:

pff_mock

I keep wondering if they’re going to part ways with Kenny Clark after this season. He turns 30 this season and has a lot of mileage (along with a contract out after this season) , and he did have kind of a down year last season, but every time I look at a first-round DT like Grant I almost feel, I don’t know how to describe it, guilty(?), like I’m unfairly predicting his playing demise, or something. Guy’s been a mainstay on the D-line since he was 20.

@packerboi posted:

Interesting observation from Ben Fennel (who knows his football pretty damn well):



I bet JohnnyZ wants to marry this guy

@Herschel posted:

I keep wondering if they’re going to part ways with Kenny Clark after this season. He turns 30 this season and has a lot of mileage (along with a contract out after this season) , and he did have kind of a down year last season, but every time I look at a first-round DT like Grant I almost feel, I don’t know how to describe it, guilty(?), like I’m unfairly predicting his playing demise, or something. Guy’s been a mainstay on the D-line since he was 20.

They have to address the position whether it's one year or two years for KC. No idea if they are re-signing Slaton either. And it's a very deep interior DL class. They would be foolish not to get at least one if not two.

@Chongo posted:

They have to address the position whether it's one year or two years for KC. No idea if they are re-signing Slaton either. And it's a very deep interior DL class. They would be foolish not to get at least one if not two.

True, I just wonder if they’d go for more of a pass rushing tackle around 300# (like Walter Nolan) rather than a 315#+ NT. Then again, Grant and Harmon are probably better prospects overall, regardless.

Also, Wyatt and Brooks kind of fill that role. The funny thing is Wyatt is only 2 1/2 years younger than Clark.

Last edited by Herschel
@Herschel posted:

True, I just wonder if they’d go for more of a pass rushing tackle around 300# (like Walter Nolan) rather than a 315#+ NT. Then again, Grant and Harmon are probably better prospects overall, regardless.

Also, Wyatt and Brooks kind of fill that role. The funny thing is Wyatt is only 2 1/2 years younger than Clark.

They need interior pass rush more than a hogger. If Grant falls, wouldn't be shocked if he's the pick. Don't think he will be there. As far as edge does, Ezieuaraku (sp) helped himself at the combine a lot. He will likely be gone too.

This one turned out interesting:

Trade back offer from Chiefs to get an extra #2.

1. Get a potential alpha press corner (though can play other techniques, as well) who's only 20 years old.

2. Jumbo defensive end that Gutekunst seems to prefer.

3. Potential #1 WR, even though not a deep speed guy.

4. Zach Tom-type OL who's good, very versatile but could use some weight.

5. Another potentially very good press corner. 2023 was better than 2024.

6. Big, athletic DT who can line up at either tackle spot.

8. Center with quick hands, recognizes defenses and has also played tackle and guard.

9. Late-round deep speed guy with questionable hands, a Gutekunst special.

Attachments

Images (1)
  • mceclip0
Last edited by Herschel

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×