Skip to main content

Listening to a lot of Bear fans this morning blowing their wad over Williams and his shiny new WR they took at #9 overall.

Meanwhile? Their OL is average to garbage at best.

Lucas Patrick with a PFF grade of 50.2 last year.

Nate Davis, their right guard, a PFF grade of 52. Equals to about a D+ grade.

Their tackles? Averaged PFF grades in the mid-upper 60's.

Gute's pick of Morgan isn't the flashy pick that Odunze is. And he's about to back up the truck to pay Jordan Love 50 mil year. So he uses his pick to ensure that Love is protected on his blindside for hopefully the next 8-10 years.

The Bears on the other hand could have drafted a franchise OT to protect Williams. Instead, they went with the pick to appease their fan base.

A lot of GM's are playing checkers this weekend. Very few are playing chess.

@CUPackFan posted:

While I don't feel for Kirk at all, what are the Falcons doing? It's one thing to have a long-term QB at the end of his career and drafting a replacement in the late first but another thing to sign an aging QB to a huge deal in free agency and then take a QB in the top 10.  The benefit of a young QB is a low cap hit. Cousins contract totally negates that.

Cousins has essentially a two-year deal and the Falcons donโ€™t want to end up in the same shithole in 2026.

@vitaflo posted:

And this is why the Packers will continue to have success.  You can't build a team with only a few picks.

Add on to this MN only has like 4 picks all of next year as well (a 1st and then they don't pick again until the 5th).  The Bears have 4 picks in the entire draft this year.  4!

Not sure how MN or Chicago build around their new QB with so few picks, most of which are late rounders as it is.

GB on the other hand has had 35 picks in the last 3 years (if they don't trade up or down this year).  We're actually trying to build a team for the future around Jordan.

The Bears have at least had a shit ton of cap space to sign free agents.

Last edited by Herschel
@Herschel posted:

Cousins has essentially a two-year deal and the Falcons donโ€™t want to end up in the same shithole in 2026.

The dead cap hits on Cousins contracts if they move on make it completely impossible to move on from him the next two years. While possible to move on in 2026, it's not without some cap pain. I guess teams eat 25 million in cap room more often these days, but this still reeks of poor planning.

https://www.spotrac.com/nfl/pl...id/9915/kirk-cousins

Dead cap hits: 2024 (90 million), 2025 (65 million), 2026 (25 million)

The thing that doesn't make sense is that one of Penix's strengths is that his age and experience make him a very developed player already. He's not a guy that you'd think would need to sit on the bench and learn the ropes for 2 years before playing. He's a more mature prospect than any QB drafted last night and you'd think his experience would lend to playing at the NFL level right away. He's also basically the same age as Desmond Ridder - the guy they already gave up on after drafting him in the 3rd round in 2022.

The Falcons will never admit it, but I assume if they knew they were sure to get Penix they would have never signed Cousins to begin with (and certainly wouldn't have tampered and likely lost draft picks because of it).

https://www.pff.com/news/draft...-penix-jr-washington

SUMMARY

Michael Penix Jr. enjoyed a long and, ultimately, successful college career. His experience can be an argument for him having a rather high floor as a draft prospect. Add to that his arm talent and ability to get through his progressions effectively and efficiently, and you have a case to be made for a first-round pick.

On the flip side of that experience is the argument that, after five seasons in college, we know exactly what he is as a quarterback and there isnโ€™t much of a ceiling. His accuracy was a problem throughout his college career. That not being fixed at this point makes it tough to think it will get better at the next level. And while he has shown an ability to avoid sacks, his struggles to make positive plays under pressure will only be more difficult when making the jump to the next level.


The Falcons will never admit it, but I assume if they knew they were sure to get Penix they would have never signed Cousins to begin with

I don't know how the Falcons didn't think they could land Penix.  He wasn't mocked high and they always had the 8th pick even before they signed Cousins.

And you're right that Penix was one of the few guys people thought were NFL ready because he spent 6 years (!) playing QB in college.  He already had 2 years playing QB in college when Love was drafted.

Having the guy sit for another 2 years is silly.  The guy that needs to sit for two years is JJ McCarthy and MN is going to throw him to the wolves on day one.

@H5 posted:

I think J. Daniels is/will be the better QB. Their vet WRs will likely be gone when/if Wiiliams gets it. Also, if their online keeps him healthy.

We'll see if the Bears ruin Caleb....They're well on their way by not taking a LT at #9 and I could not be happier.

Packers have Jaire, Valentine & Ballentine plus Stokes and then X at Safety. I'm assuming they will select another one on day 2 here.

I'm not worried

Last edited by Boris
@vitaflo posted:

I don't know how the Falcons didn't think they could land Penix.  He wasn't mocked high and they always had the 8th pick even before they signed Cousins.

And you're right that Penix was one of the few guys people thought were NFL ready because he spent 6 years (!) playing QB in college.  He already had 2 years playing QB in college when Love was drafted.

Having the guy sit for another 2 years is silly.  The guy that needs to sit for two years is JJ McCarthy and MN is going to throw him to the wolves on day one.

I just looked this up based on your comment. Jordan Love is only 17 months older than Penix, and has never had a major surgery. Penix has had his throwing shoulder operated on in addition to having to repair both ACLS.

Keenan Allen for a 4th round pick and a 1 year deal at 23 million was a good move.

He's had some missteps (Roquan, Claypool), but otherwise Poles has been doing a really good job of building that roster.  They need improvement on the OL but there is a lot of offseason and draft still ahead of them.  Their RD1 RT last year was on the all rookie team.

The clincher is whether or not they have the HC and OC to compliment what will be a top 10, possibly top 5 D if they stay healthy.  Bears fans and other sources love to point to Mahomes as a comp.  Aside from that being an incredible reach because of how good Mahomes is, Mahomes also has a HOF coach and one of  the best offensive minds since Walsh.

Last edited by DH13


The Falcons will never admit it, but I assume if they knew they were sure to get Penix they would have never signed Cousins to begin with (and certainly wouldn't have tampered and likely lost draft picks because of it).

If the stuff coming out now is accurate, the Vikings, Saints, Raiders and Seahawks were all trying to trade up with Atlanta for Penix, and the Falcons stunned them all. Yep, the Vikings supposedly had Penix over McCarthy, as well.

Last edited by Herschel
@Herschel posted:

Yep, the Vikings supposedly had Penix over McCarthy, as well.

The Queenies also had Drake Maye over Penix & McCarthy.

Interesting day yesterday. Wonder when Eliot Wolf will get to drive that Lamborghini in New England? If he had his way, the Pats trade down, then probably back up to get Penix.

@ilcuqui posted:

From various folks on Twitter:

The #Packers were just mentioned on NFLN as a team looking to move up to the top of the 2nd round...

None of which is surprising. They did it for Watson.

Last edited by Boris
@Floridarob posted:

can we get the way back machine and see how IC felt about Joshua Jackson? Just for kicks and giggles...

Even better....Abdul "The Butcher" Hodge ๐Ÿคซ

Moving right along ....

Last edited by Boris

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×