Skip to main content

@michiganjoe posted:

From the piece:

Late in the first half and trailing by seven points, the Vikings faced first-and-goal from the Lions 3. O'Connell called for running back Dalvin Cook to take a handoff and make a jump pass to tight end Johnny Mundt.

Really a bizarre call in that situation.

Another example of a coach trying to prove he's smarter than everybody else.

@michiganjoe posted:

From the piece:

Late in the first half and trailing by seven points, the Vikings faced first-and-goal from the Lions 3. O'Connell called for running back Dalvin Cook to take a handoff and make a jump pass to tight end Johnny Mundt.

Really a bizarre call in that situation.

Didn’t see the play, it sounds like. The same play the Titans successfully ran against the Packers.

@Tschmack posted:

The Vikings are in serious trouble.  

There’s almost no chance the Vikings can surpass the Eagles given they are 2 back + head to head loss.   Of all the teams in the playoff chase no one needs that first round bye more than Minnesota.  

I really don't think it matters whether they get the bye or not.  They're not going to beat PHI and most likely couldn't beat SF unless SF starts falling apart before the playoffs.  Same goes for facing DAL.  The best MIN can hope for is a RD1 win vs a WC team if they get seeded that way.  That's their ceiling this year.

Ouch.  How long has it been since we've had a stud defensive coordinator?  Fritz?

We all loved Fritz, but his defensive line was Reggie White, Sean Jones, Santana Dotson, and Gilbert Brown. In other words, the best defensive lineman in NFL history, another guy with 113 career sacks (Jones), one of the best interior pass rushers in football at the time (Dotson), and a premier run stuffer. It is without question a top 10 DL in NFL history.

His LBs weren't at that level, but he had one of the best guys to cover a TE ever (Simmons), one of the fastest LBs in the league (Brian Williams), and a solid MLB (Koonce).

He had a HOF safety (Butler) paired with a free safety with 57 career interceptions along with three good corners (pre-injury Newsome, Evans, and Tyrone Williams).

Shurmur had some bottom 10 defenses at previous stops. He knew enough not to screw up the mid 90s Packers defense, but that side of the ball was loaded.

Last edited by MichiganPacker

We all loved Fritz, but his defensive line was Reggie White, Sean Jones, Santana Dotson, and Gilbert Brown. In other words, the best defensive lineman in NFL history, another guy with 113 career sacks (Jones), one of the best interior pass rushers in football at the time (Dotson), and a premier run stuffer. It is without question a top 10 DL in NFL history.

His LBs weren't at that level, but he had one of the best guys to cover a TE ever (Simmons), one of the fastest LBs in the league (Brian Williams), and a solid MLB (Koonce).

He had a HOF safety (Butler) paired with a free safety with 57 career interceptions along with three good corners (pre-injury Newsome, Evans, and Tyrone Williams).

Shurmur had some bottom 10 defenses at previous stops. He knew enough not to screw up the mid 90s Packers defense, but that side of the ball was loaded.

You realize the coaching was a big part of that success in that he played to their strengths . Give that defense to Barry and they would be a middling to fair defense.

Last edited by Goalline
@Goalline posted:

You realize the coaching was a big part of that success in that he played to their strengths . Give that defense to Barry and they would be a middling to fair defense.

Here's all the rankings of every defense Shurmur ever coordinated (from footballreference.com). A very mixed bag.

I'm not sure even Joe Barry could reduce Reggie's effectiveness, but you can't rule it out.



Screen Shot 2022-12-13 at 5.23.55 PM

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Screen Shot 2022-12-13 at 5.23.55 PM

Here's all the rankings of every defense Shurmur ever coordinated (from footballreference.com). A very mixed bag.

I'm not sure even Joe Barry could reduce Reggie's effectiveness, but you can't rule it out.



Screen Shot 2022-12-13 at 5.23.55 PM

He coached that 1991 Phoenix Cardinal D to 27th? That's a hell of an accomplishment. That D was brutal. Totally devoid in talent. Barry would have coached that team to the 345th position. Yes, below every D1 college program.

Reggie? Barry would have moved him to corner to patrol the secondary in his special soft zone coverage schemes.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×