Skip to main content

Pick #13 from this draft is averaging less than 1 tackle a game.  

Gute has turned this Org into the Raiders.   A bunch of super fast athletes that can’t play football.    Amazing high jump and a propensity to commit penalties.  

Gute has been building for this season since the day he drafted Love.   Let that sink in…..   This shit show you see is his master plan.  

Im torn on if I want him fired or not because that would just mean Murphy picks the next guy.  

I think we’re fucked with no hope for a couple years.

Upcoming schedule

Rams

at Steelers

Chargers

at Lions

Chiefs

It's already ugly, but if they don't win next week against the Rams (and I don't think they will), they will likely be looking at a 2-10 record and a 9 game losing streak.

The last 5 games are all winnable, even for the shitty team they are this year (at Giants, Bucs, at Panthers, at Vikings with no cousins, Bears).

Probably the worst thing that could happen is to go into those last 5 games at 2-10 and then win 3 of the last 5 so that the narrative in the front office is that they have "momentum."

Unless the show some life the next 5 games, they need to burn the whole thing down and start over.

@BrainDed posted:

Gute has been building for this season since the day he drafted Love.   Let that sink in…..   This shit show you see is his master plan.  

Im torn on if I want him fired or not because that would just mean Murphy picks the next guy.  

I think we’re fucked with no hope for a couple years.

I think one more year and Murphy hits mandatory retirement.

Right.  Thus the “couple of years”.

Maybe the best thing for our future is to retain Gute and staff for one more year.   Then Murphy leaves and the new guy can pick his own front office.  

@packerboi posted:

There's some legitimacy in players needing to be battle tested. But not scarred. The Cleveland Browns have scars.

Last edited by packerboi

How many GM's in the NFL had Josh Myers rated ahead of Creed Humphrey when Gutey took Myers and that team that knows nothing over in KC took Humphrey with the very next pick?

If fans expect a mea culpa from Gutey regarding Myers, they just have not been paying attention to how the "smartest GM in the NFL" conducts his business.

If someone were to do a full analysis of every decision every GM has made.  You would find a mix of good/bad moves across the board.  If you considered everything (including relative draft positions) and came up with rankings I’d bet Gutey would still grade out pretty well overall.  

It’s really easy to zero in on each decision but that doesn’t show the whole picture.  It’s short sighted.

Gute’s and the scouts biggest successes from 2018-2021 were bringing in new experienced NFL players like the Smith brothers, Amos, Turner, Rasul, etc.  They were excellent on that front when they had cap room.  

The below average drafting sabotaged all the excellent work on pro personnel evaluation.  With poor college talent evaluations, they weren’t able to supplement what they already had and also caused a huge cap problem.  The only thing that could have saved them is if they would have hit the jackpot with Love being a franchise QB.  Sadly, so far it looks like Love will fall significantly short of what it would take to make up for all the other poor draft picks.

@packerboi posted:

Screenshot_20230911_090256

@SteveLuke posted:

How many GM's in the NFL had Josh Myers rated ahead of Creed Humphrey when Gutey took Myers and that team that knows nothing over in KC took Humphrey with the very next pick?

If fans expect a mea culpa from Gutey regarding Myers, they just have not been paying attention to how the "smartest GM in the NFL" conducts his business.

yep, this guys is preparing us for his 're-signing' - get ready for it.  smartest guy in the room baby!

To be fair, let's break down Gutey's sentence. "The best football since he's been here." A 1 out of 100 is better than a 0 out of 100, no? Maybe he's making sure he's wiping his butt sweat whenever he's on the sidelines. Surely that's worth 1 point.

@Benzene posted:

If someone were to do a full analysis of every decision every GM has made.  You would find a mix of good/bad moves across the board.  If you considered everything (including relative draft positions) and came up with rankings I’d bet Gutey would still grade out pretty well overall.  

It’s really easy to zero in on each decision but that doesn’t show the whole picture.  It’s short sighted.

the grade should be based on the team on the field.  this team sucks and trading douglas for the equivalent of a fourth round pick doesn’t make it better

the grade should be based on the team on the field.  this team sucks and trading douglas for the equivalent of a fourth round pick doesn’t make it better

Agree. Gute is a big part of the problem.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×